Silver Fern Flag
  • Store
  • Licence
    • Apply
  • Press
  • Flag
  • Contact

PRESS

MEDIA ARTICLES
Store

Former Green MP Supports Silver Fern Flag

29/2/2016

1 Comment

 
Picture
Two years ago I welcomed John Key’s promise to hold a flag referendum. At last we could get rid of the Union Jack from our flag and have one that didn’t look like Australia’s. Many on the left had long argued for a flag change and now we had some significant support from the right.

Now it seems that many leftists will be joining the Anglophiles in voting to keep our present colonial flag. Let’s look at the reasons they give for changing their stance and the counter-arguments.

1. The referendum is a waste of taxpayers’ money. That is essentially an argument for never having a referendum, because it will always cost money. However, I do accept that some of the early expenditure – to find out about our “values” – was unnecessary.

2. Changing the flag isn’t a priority. Obviously, combating the TPPA or dealing with the housing crisis are more urgent issues, but it is not a zero sum game. Changing the flag is about us developing a greater sense of nationhood, which has progressive ramifications across other political issues. The Union Jack in our flag symbolises a neo-colonial mentality which is still present, even if the imperial power we now tip our hat to is usually the United States. A greater sense of independence would mean we’d be less trusting of America over the TPPA or New Zealand’s participation in America’s wars. Be careful about using the “it isn’t a priority” argument. It’s regularly used by politicians to avoid dealing with controversial issues: like marijuana law reform, assisted dying legislation and improving the abortion laws.

3. Changing the flag is a diversion. I find that argument a bit patronising to New Zealanders. We are grown up enough to engage with the flag issue, or not, as we wish. We are only diverted to the extent we want to be diverted. And there are some important underlying political issues in the flag debate, as I have explained above.

4. Who cares about the flag anyhow? Isn’t flag-waving a reactionary nationalist exercise? I have considerable sympathy for that stance, particularly when you see how patriotism and flag-waving is used by the political right in America, Britain, Australia, France, etc. But if we are going to wave a flag at to wave at international sports events, etc., I prefer it wasn’t our present colonial flag.

5. It’s John Key’s flag. John Key was still a money-trader when Kyle Lockwood designed the flag back in 2001. Before John Key got involved there were many people (including myself) campaigning for a flag change – many of whom liked the Lockwood design. It won flag design competitions.

6. The Lockwood design is too bad to vote for. Fair enough if you really don’t like it don’t vote for it. People differ on what is a good design and a lot of people will disagree with any design chosen. Given the way symbols have been used in New Zealand in recent years the most popular flag was always going to have either a fern or a koru on it, and perhaps a southern cross. Kyle Lockwood’s design won because it combined two of these symbols and for traditionalists it didn’t depart too much from the original flag, with a southern cross on a blue background.

7. The process to select an alternative flag was just so bad. True, the selection committee was weak on design expertise. It should have done some development work on the best, or most popular, designs. Also, the process of selecting the final four designs for the initial referendum was clearly flawed. Two of the final four designs (the black and white koru and fern ones) were duds. Better and more popular designs, like the modified Hundertwasser koru or Otis Frizzell’s koru and stars, could have been in the final four.

8. We can have another go at changing the flag at a future time (perhaps when John Key has gone). The truth is that you’ve got to seize chances to bring about progressive change as they arise. Really, which party is going to start another referendum process any time soon? Labour??

9. The campaign for the fern flag is a John Key, National Party, business leaders and elite sportspeople campaign. To me the first rule of politics is that you judge an issue on whether it is progressive or not, rather than who is supporting it. It is good if some on the right support a progressive issue. National Party supporters like Dan Carter might have been more in the media, but the Change the New Zealand Flag campaign also includes a lot of people not aligned to National, like Roger Hall and Oscar Knightly. International sportspeople like Silver Fern Maria Tutaia have good reasons to support a flag change, particularly when the Aussie and NZ flags get mixed up at international events. And we shouldn’t be against business people wanting a more distinctive New Zealand branding.

10. A defeat for the fern flag will be a defeat for John Key. I’m afraid the opposite is true. Of course, John Key has too closely identified himself with the fern flag design. But if people who want a flag change for good and genuine reasons see Labour and the left responsible for keeping the colonial flag then the only political victor, unfortunately, will be John Key and his National Party.

Keith Locke.

- See more at: http://thedailyblog.co.nz/2016/03/01/odd-alignments-in-the-flag-debate/#.dpuf
1 Comment

    MEDIA


    Buy Flag

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    December 2022
    December 2021
    August 2021
    December 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    March 2020
    December 2019
    March 2019
    January 2019
    September 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    July 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    July 2014
    February 2014
    August 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    April 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011

    Pre 2012 Articles

    Categories

    All
    All Whites
    ANZAC
    Architectural Designer
    Austin Woods
    Australian
    BBC
    Bill English
    Boer War
    Christchurch United FC
    Czech Republic
    David Shearer
    Dawn French
    Fairfax
    Flag Of Canada
    Flag Of Jamaica
    Flag Referendum 2
    Gary Brown
    Green Party MP
    John Key
    Kip Colvey
    Kyle Lockwood
    Labour
    Licensing
    Lifewear
    London
    Lt Col Chris Mullane
    Malcolm Mulholland
    Maori
    New Zealand Army
    New Zealand Flag
    New Zealand Flag Facts
    N Z Elite Triathlon Team
    N Z Flag
    NZ Flag Consideration Project
    NZ Flag Poll Vote!
    NZ Flag Poll - Vote!
    NZ Listener
    One News
    Otago Daily Times
    Preferred Alternative New Zealand Flag
    Professor Andrew Russell
    Referendum
    Republic Of New Zealand
    RSA
    Scottish Indepandence
    Silver Fern
    Silver Fern Flag
    Sir Edmund Hillary
    Southern Cross
    UK
    U K
    Union Flag
    Union Jack
    Victoria & Albert
    Walk Of Fame
    WW1
    WW2

​©2000-2024 Kyle Lockwood
Director, Architecture Ltd ​T/A Silver Fern Flag, incorporated in Wellington in 2006. We are not​​ in any way affiliated with the 
NZ Government. 
  • Store
  • Licence
    • Apply
  • Press
  • Flag
  • Contact